Making your own goat milk soap at home is one of the most rewarding homestead skills you can learn. It’s creamy, nourishing, and naturally gentle on sensitive skin — and once you make it yourself, you’ll never want store-bought again.
If you raise goats or have access to fresh milk, this is a beautiful way to use it. But even store-bought goat milk works perfectly.
Today I’m walking you through a simple cold process goat milk soap recipe that’s beginner-friendly and produces a rich, moisturizing bar every time.
Why Make Goat Milk Soap?
Goat milk soap is known for:
- Naturally moisturizing properties
- Gentle cleansing for sensitive skin
- Creamy lather
- Rich vitamins and fatty acids
- No harsh detergents
It’s a favorite for homesteaders, gardeners, and anyone wanting a more natural skincare routine.
Supplies You’ll Need
- Digital kitchen scale
- Safety goggles
- Rubber gloves
- Stainless steel or heavy-duty plastic bowls
- Stick blender
- Silicone soap mold
- Thermometer
- Parchment paper
⚠️ Always use proper safety precautions when working with lye.
Ingredients
- 10 oz frozen goat milk (cubed)
- 4.5 oz lye (sodium hydroxide)
- 20 oz olive oil
- 10 oz coconut oil
- 5 oz castor oil
- Optional: essential oils (lavender, rosemary, or eucalyptus)
Step-by-Step Instructions
Step 1: Freeze the Goat Milk
Pour goat milk into ice cube trays and freeze solid. This prevents scorching when adding lye.
Step 2: Mix Lye & Milk
Slowly sprinkle lye into frozen milk cubes (never the other way around). Stir gently until dissolved. Keep temperature under 90–100°F to avoid discoloration.
Step 3: Melt Oils
Melt coconut oil, then combine with olive oil and castor oil. Allow oils to cool to about 90–100°F.
Step 4: Blend to Trace
Slowly pour lye mixture into oils. Use a stick blender until mixture reaches “trace” (pudding-like consistency).
Step 5: Add Fragrance (Optional)
Stir in essential oils if using.
Step 6: Pour into Mold
Pour into silicone mold and gently tap to release air bubbles.
Step 7: Cure
Let sit 24–48 hours before unmolding.
Cure bars in a cool, dry place for 4–6 weeks before use.
Tips for Creamy White Goat Milk Soap
- Keep temperatures low
- Use frozen milk
- Avoid overheating
- Do not insulate heavily
This helps maintain that beautiful creamy color instead of turning tan.
Storage
Store cured bars in a dry area with airflow. Properly cured soap lasts 1+ years.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is goat milk soap good for sensitive skin?
Yes — it’s known for being gentle and moisturizing.
Can I use store-bought goat milk?
Absolutely. Just freeze it first before mixing with lye.
Why does my soap turn brown?
Milk scorched due to high temperatures. Keep it cool during mixing.
Final Thoughts
Learning how to make goat milk soap is one of those timeless skills that feels deeply satisfying — especially if you’re already embracing a more natural, from-scratch lifestyle.
Once you try it, you may never go back to commercial soap again.

cute!!
Thanks 🙂
I “love” it! I just went to a women’s relaxation event and brought home lavender, so maybe this should be on my list of things to try…
Yes! Do it! So easy and a great project to do with the kids as well 🙂
So pretty! I love lavender.
Oh me too! Especially in my bath products 🙂
Alright- so smart- so gosh dang cute smart! L-O-V-E
Will you be my Valentine?
-Jen
haha…of course, but only is if you bring the menage a tois…wait…that sounded dirty… 😉 XO
ADORABLE… I have sensitive skin and love the idea to know what is in my soap!
It is luxury at a very reasonable price!!!
Thanks!
Claudine
Sure is! Every girl needs to be pampered every once in a while! Thanks for stopping by! XO
I’ll bet it smells so good!
It sure does! Love lavender 🙂
Oh my gosh – these are beautiful Christine!! I have never made soap before but have always wanted to and now you have inspired me to try! Thanks so much for linking up your creativity at IT’s Party Time!!
It’s so easy! Go for it, and let me know how yours turns out! Thanks for the feature today!!
I featured you today here! http://www.settingforfour.com/2013/01/its-party-time-1-20-2013-linky-party.html Thanks so much for linking up your beautiful valentine’s soaps last week – hope to see more of your awesomeness at this week’s It’s Party Time!
Yay!! Thanks so much! XO
How did you carve “love” so perfectly into the soap? Did you use a special knife or just a really sharp one? They are so cute! Thanks!!
No special knife. Just a sharp paring knife and scraped it lightly, running the soap under warm water every once in a while so the edges of the word melted a bit. I’m not going to lie…it took a little while to make it look photo ready 😉
Lavender is so soothing! You can also dissolve a few drops in water, boil out the impurities, and put it in a spray bottle to spritz on your face or hair for a calming affect.
Just stopping by to let you know I included this post in my favorite craft projects for February. These were the most popular posts on my Facebook page during February as well, so thank you for such a great project! You can see the round up here http://craftsbyamanda.com/2014/03/great-craft-ideas-february-2014.html 🙂